Every house owner with a vacant backyard dreams about his/her own pool. However, inground constructions are messy and expensive, while inflatable models last for one season only. Above-ground frame pools become that perfect way out that combines affordability, ease of installation and maintenances, as well as sufficient place for swimming/resting.
If you’d also like to get something fast and worry-free for mounting, our Coleman vs Intex pools comparison will answer all your questions.
We’re going to examine five best-selling models and then will decide which product suits you best. All models are presented in the comparison table.
Coleman vs Intex Brand Comparison
Coleman is a famous American Brand for producing outdoor recreation products – coolers, tents, sleeping bags, grills, stoves, and other camp furniture. It was founded in 1900 year. Newell Brands now owns Coleman.
Unfortunately, now swimming pools with Coleman trademark are produced by licensed partner – Bestway Company. And starting from Power Steel Vista Series, all pools are developed and manufactured by Bestway.
Bestway, since 1994 specialized in above-ground pools, sport, and camping goods, more than 1000 products. You can buy Bestway Power Steel pools or Coleman Power Steel pools that are actually the same on the market, and the spares are suitable for both marks.
Intex Recreation Company is also a famous American brand with more than 50 years of history of beach balls, swimming pools, boats, etc. The only item that Company produces not for a swim is airbeds. The former company name was Wet Set. The first Intex above ground swimming pool was made in 1997.
The Company poses a lot of patents showing significant research works done for the production of high-quality leisure goods.
As Bestway, Intex is a reliable pool brand; they both have all the required accessories to maintain the pool in good order, such as pumps and filtration systems. In addition, Intex has a massive range of models of above-ground pools available at different prices.
Both pool brands produce good quality swimming pools experienced for many years by lucky users.
To understand which brand is more suitable for your needs, please check all pros and cons below.
Intex vs Coleman Main differences
Even though both Companies are trustable in swimming leisure products, there are some critical differences between them:
- Coleman does not produce their swimming pools; these pools are produced by their partner – Bestway.
- Intex has a broader model range of above-ground swimming pools, including small inflatable pools for kids and framed big ones (plastic and metal); meanwhile, Coleman is represented mainly with metal frame models.
- Intex also produces a lot of accessories, while for Coleman, all additional accessories should be bought from Bestway that perfectly suits the pools. Also, the choice from Intex is a little bit more for all accessories.
- There is an option to buy an Intex pool without all kits and pumps (if you already have everything), only a pool; this makes it very affordable.
- Intex swimming pools mainly have more choices with affordable prices.
Other differences are better to check on comparing the most popular pool models of these brands.
Comparison Table
Main Differences Between the Models
Before the detailed comparison, we’d like to list the essential differences between our pools. Below, you can see what to focus on during your choice and get the key information if you don’t have much time to read the whole review.
- Firstly, pools differ in size. While dimension variations are not that dramatic, we notice more significant changes in water capacity. Intex EH series pools are golden mean with 15ft x 48in size and 4440 gal capacity. Its Intex FBA brother is the most compact option with 12ft x 30in dimensions and only 1718 gal capacity. In the Coleman vs Intex pools battle, Colemans win the title of the largest constructions (18ft x 48in and 6092 gal.).
- Surprisingly, both manufacturers use the same frames and liners for their pools. However, some models got improved frame joining. Colemans reinforced all constructions with Seal & Lock system. And with Intex, only the 15ft x 48″ 26725EH uses T-joints.
- Because of the varying dimensions and water capacity, we naturally evidence the difference in filter pump flow rates. The detailed information on this characteristic is presented in the comparison table.
- Finally, the first two Intex pools feature the ultimate set of accessories. The third Intex lacks all extras, except for the compulsory pump. Coleman above-ground pools are somewhere in the middle and lack only a ground cloth.
1. Intex 28241EH 15ft x 48in Metal Frame Above-ground Pool
View on Amazon
The first model we’re going to discuss provides 15ft x 48in swimming space. All in all, large capacity is the main pool’s advantage.
Otherwise, this Intex features pretty simple and solid construction. We like a metal frame and special triple strong, super-tough laminated sidewalls. Liner and poles are reinforced to withstand up to 4440 gallons of water. The amount of water is not a problem since Intex included dual suction outlet fittings that improve water circulation.
According to users’ reviews, assembling takes about 40 minutes. Thanks to a special inbuilt drain plug, it also won’t take much time to fill and drain the pool.
One more plus of this product is a rich kit. Apart from the pool, you also have an Intex brand Krystal Clear filter pump, a ladder, a ground cloth, and a pool cover. Thus, customers get as many as five products in one purchase!
The only cons we managed to highlight are the pretty high price and weak pump operation. However, in our opinion, the price is just considering the number of accessories, while the pump traditionally provides basic performance sufficient for stated water capacity.
- pretty large pool for the whole family
- quick and simple installation
- solid metal frame and reinforced liner
- excellent accessory kit
- free filter pump, ladder, ground cloth, and pool cover
- improved water circulation
- expensive
- very simple filter pump
- kids will need your supervision
- requires a thorough choice of a flat place for installation
2. Intex 15ft x 48″ 26725EH Round Prism Frame Above-ground Pool
View on Amazon
The 26725EH modification features extremely close characteristics to the previous product. The list of similarities includes the same 15ft x 48in size, 4440 gal capacity, accessories, materials. So, why should we discuss this model here?
Intex 26725EH is an improved above-ground pool. It boasts a quality powder-coated steel frame and a slightly different 3-ply material liner.
But the main improvements are special T-joint connectors between the frame poles to stand the greater weight and, at the same time, to make assembly easier. Also, this pool comes with Hydro Aeration Technology that improves water purity and circulation.
Thus, the Intex 26725EH pool suits customers who look for increased durability for adequate money. Once again, the price may seem biting, but an extra cartridge filter pump, one pool ladder, ground cloth & pool cover are worth it.
- nice capacity for the whole family
- even quicker and simpler installation
- new T-joint connectors and reinforced frame ensure the longer service life
- thick 3-ply liner
- great water quality with Hydro Aeration
- comes with a filter pump, ladder, ground cloth, and pool cover
- quick draining
- expensive
- very simple filter pump
- kids will need your supervision
- requires a thorough choice of a flat place for installation
3. Intex FBA_28211EH 12 ft x 30 in Metal Frame Pool Set
View on Amazon
If you liked the previous constructions but still look for something simpler and more affordable, welcome Intex FBA_28211EH pool. This product offers a bit smaller swimming space and no additional equipment (except for the pump). However, the durability of the frame and liner stay the same. Also, the pool is more suitable for kids and is trice more affordable.
Intex provides its usual frame construction and standard PVC liner material. Walls can resist most impacts, while frame poles assemble within 30 minutes. Altogether, the whole construction provides a 1718 gallon capacity.
Despite the lower price, this pool is equipped with our favorite Hydro Aeration technology and dual suction outlet fittings for optimal water circulation.
Finally, we still get a Krystal Clear filter pump, which is an exquisitely generous offer considering the cost.
As we said, the Intex FBA_28211EH pool is a nice choice for families with kids. It features simple yet durable construction for small money. Besides, many users state its only con is a weak pump.
- compact pool for kids and adults
- simple construction
- quick installation
- solid metal frame and PVC liner
- a filter pump is included
- excellent water quality and circulation thanks to Hydro Aeration and dual suction outlet fittings
- affordable model
- simple filter pump
- liner may leak
- requires a thorough choice of a flat place for installation
4. Coleman 18′ x 48″ Power Steel Swim Vista Series II Metal Frame Swimming Pool
View on Amazon
This season, the Coleman brand promotes its second-generation Vista above-ground frame pool. Indeed, despite the evident Coleman vs Intex pools similarity, this model has a lot to offer. And first of all, we’d like to highlight its super-large 6092 gal capacity.
Apart from being the largest frame pool in our rating, the Vista is the only one that comes with built-in portholes. Several windows ensure constant supervision after diving kids and allow for taking funny photos.
When it comes to frame, engineers complemented steel poles with Coleman patented Seal & Lock System joints for a sturdy and simple connection. The liner will also serve long due to Tritech multi-layer material.
Finally, we’d like to mention a unique rattan wicker print that perfectly and naturally matches any backyard.
Apart from the pool, you also get one filter pump, one ladder, and one pool cover.
Certainly, Coleman Vista offers durability compared with inground pools but features a lower price and easier installation. We’d recommend this model for adults who need some space for swimming.
But please mind that the size and kit will cost you over $1000. Also, we noticed no water circulation tools, which is a drawback for such water capacity. Finally, though windows are funny, they increase the chance of leakage.
- the largest pool in our review
- Coleman frame that lasts several seasons
- Seal & Lock joint connectors with an easy lock system
- improved Tritech liner
- porthole windows for safety and fun
- free cartridge filter pump
- a removable pool ladder and a pool cover included
- a drain plug
- quick assembly
- expensive
- the pump flow rate may be insufficient for such water capacity
- no systems for water circulation support
- porthole windows may leak
5. Coleman 18′ x 48″ Power Steel Deluxe Series Metal Frame Above-ground Pool
View on Amazon
As we’ve mentioned above, the Vista features lots of pros, but its windows often scare away customers. Coleman took care of this problem and presented its Coleman Deluxe frame pool.
Generally speaking, Deluxe is a twin of the Coleman Vista model. It provides us with the same swimming area and water capacity, frame and liner materials, Seal & Lock System.
The kit is also identical: one cartridge filter pump, one free ladder and a complimentary pool cover.
The main change is no windows. On the one hand, you won’t be able to look after your kids when they dive anymore. But many users find this lack a blessing since leaks are minimized now.
We definitely recommend Coleman Deluxe construction as it provides just the same level of durability and convenience, at the same time being twice more affordable compared to the previous Coleman pools and Intex pools. Deluxe will suit families with kids and adult customers who need a spacious and simple pool for summer.
- the largest pool in our review
- excellent and durable steel frame
- Seal & Lock system for extra durability
- improved Tritech liner
- free cartridge filter pump
- a removable pool ladder and a pool cover included
- the same natural design
- a drain plug
- minimum leakages
- quick assembly
- affordable
- pump still leaves much to desire
- no systems for water circulation support
Face to Face Comparison
Now when we got the key pools’ characteristics, let us compare each feature separately and find our best-suit product.
Design and Dimensions
As a rule, pool manufacturers classify their products by size and pool capacity. That’s why we can find all dimension information in the models’ names. Anyway, let us list the sizes one more time. All five models have the following dimensions and water capacity:
Intex 28241EH 15ft x 48in Pool
- 15ft x 48in
- 4440 gallons
Intex 15ft x 48in 26725EH Pool
- 15ft x 48in
- 4440 gallons
Intex FBA_28211EH 12ft x 30in Pool
- 12ft x 30in
- 1718 gallons
Coleman 18′ x 48” Vista Pool
- 18ft x 48in
- 6092 gallons
Coleman 18′ x 48″ Deluxe Pool
- 18ft x 48in
- 6092 gallons
Well, there is no great difference in terms of dimensions between our competitors, but you still can choose a bigger product for swimming or a smaller pool for kids.
Offered colors also coincide within the brand series. Thus, all Intex pools are made in standard blue shades. Only the Intex 26725EH Pool uses a grey outfit with a blue inner covering.
Colemans chose more natural print imitating rattan wicker. This is a nice decision since your camouflage-like pool will be completely invisible and native in the backyard.
Frame and Assembly
The frame is the main and essential part of rigid above-ground pools. Materials, construction, connectors – all these elements influence, firstly, how safe the pool will be and, secondly, for how long it will serve.
Here, we’d like to find out what of the Coleman vs Intex pool choices will become a long-term investment.
- Intex 28241EH 15ft x 48in Pool
The first Intex pool comes with a powder-coated rust-resistant steel frame. The frame consists of standard metal poles and equally standard connectors that fix them. Everything is cheap and cheerful, as they say. But the quality is tested. - Intex 15ft x 48in 26725EH Pool
The Intex 26725EH features an improved prism frame. While the poles are made of the same powder-coated steel, a new method of connection is represented here. The system is called T-joints, and they fix three poles (one vertical and two transverse tubes). Besides, the vertical one is held tighter. Thus, the whole system becomes much more rigid and durable. - Intex FBA_28211EH 12ft x 30in Pool
When it comes to the FBA modification, engineers used the basic frame for it. We notice 100% identical steel poles that we’ve already met in the first Intex pool and simple connectors. - Coleman Vista and Deluxe 18′ x 48” Pools
We’ll describe both Colemans together since they have no difference. First of all, users get corrosion and rust-resistant steel frame. All in all, it is similar to the Intex frame though Coleman’s poles look wider and thicker.
Also, tubes are equipped with the Seal & Lock System, which is an alternative to Intex T-Joints.
Both manufacturers state the assembly takes about 30 minutes. Our tests show it’s not quite true. Assembly usually lasts for 45-60 minutes, especially if you’re alone and have no experience in pool installation. Still, for us, even a twice longer process feels pretty quick.
verdictHere, we’d like to highlight Intex 15ft x 48in 26725EH Pool and both Coleman pools as they offer us special pole connectors. The systems ensure ultimate support for many years. However, if we consider the speed and convenience of assembly, simple Intex models will slightly win.
Liner
While frames ensure steadiness and support, the liner keeps water inside. In fact, fifty percent of pool durability depends on the liner.
Despite the vague explanations and stated differences, all Coleman and Intex pools come with the same 3-ply liner. It is made of PVC material consisted of three layers. Two outside layers provide protection against weather and sun impacts, hits, punctures, stretching, friction. The middle layer gives additional thickness and reinforcement.
The only difference lies in names. While Intex calls it 3-ply, Coleman prefers Tritech system title.
verdictWe cannot choose a winner here as all frame pools share the same liner material and technology. All we can state is that the 3-ply PVC walls are thick and durable, but, unfortunately, punctures and leakages are still possible.
Filter Pump
All five products come with complementary (and absolutely necessary) cartridge filter pumps. These units allow for:
- proper water pumping;
- eliminating major pool pollutants such as leaves, insects, sediment;
- improving water circulation.
The pumps share the same appearance and functions. However, they differ in power and flow rate.
Intex models use their own brand pumps by Krystal Clear series.
Intex 28241EH and Intex 26725EH pool pumps produce 1000 gallons per hour. The declared water/system flow rate is 750 GPH.
The third Intex, smaller FBA_28211EH 12ft x 30in pool features equivalent but twice smaller 530 GPH filter pump. Consequently, its water/system flow rate is almost twice less too and forms 475 GPM. However, the FBA pump is the only one that is equipped with the Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter. This feature automatically turns the pump off in case of accidental moisturizing and increased risk of short circuit.
Coleman 18′ x 48″ Vista and Deluxe pools offer the most powerful pumps that process up to 1500 GPH. The system flow rate is unstated, though we can conclude it’s over 900 GPH.
All filter pumps require standard 110-120V.
attentionPlease also mind that, regardless of GPH, filter pumps deal greatly with large and medium-sized debris. However, we do not recommend them for fine particles.
Also, users note that pumps offer very simple, basic-level water treatment that feels inadequate of stated water capacities. Indeed, one cannot expect something super-powerful for this money, but we believe pumps and filters to be sufficient for main tasks.
Well, the final choice is yours here. Anyway, remember that you can get a more powerful pump as a replacement since all pools are easily compatible with other pumping and filtering products.
verdictIn our opinion, an extra filtering pump is a nice complement to the pool kit. The manufacturers save our money and provide us with a free pump (and we’ll need them anyway). Besides, pumps are selected according to the water capacity, which cannot be overestimated.
Thus, in terms of efficiency, you can choose any pool. But we’d like to focus on the Intex FBA model due to its extra safety tip.
Hydro Aeration
Hydro Aeration is an Intex own technology aimed at the improvement of pool water quality. However, many other reputable pool equipment manufacturers implement equivalent technologies in their products.
To put it short, the system acts in several directions. The tiny construction mixes water with air bubbles from outside. Thus, it increases water circulation, enriches water with ions, and directs dirt particles into the filter.
Only two out of three of our competitors boast this technology. They are Intex 15ft x 48in 26725EH and Intex FBA_28211EH 12ft x 30in pools.
verdictEvidently, Intex pools are leaders in this field, so they justly get the privilege in our Coleman vs Intex pools comparison.
Draining
Pool filling usually takes about an hour (or an hour and a half if you have a large pool and weak water pressure). However, emptying is a more time-consuming process. And if we consider the necessity for regular pool draining for cleaning, we’ll realize how important a proper draining system is.
The draining systems of all our pools coincide. Both brands took care of our time and equipped their models with drain plugs. These small and simple units serve as a cork, but after the opening, they allow for attaching a hose. Please mind that depending on your hose, you may need a drain adapter that can be bought separately.
verdictUnlike many cheap above-ground pools, our Colemans and Intexes don’t have any problems with quick drainage. All models will require several minutes for draining, so you can safely get any pool for our review.
Accessories
As we see, Intex and Coleman pools we’re discussing are pricy. Frankly speaking, it frightens many customers out. However, such price greatly depends on the accessories.
The maximum pool kit available in the market includes:
- filter pumps;
- removable ladders;
- pool covers;
- and ground cloths.
We’ve already discussed the meaning of pumps, so let us emit this here. The function of a ladder is also pretty obvious. We will only add that all ladders measure 48in high (to fit the pools), withstand up to 300 pounds, and feature corrosion-resistant frame and slip-resistant step design.
Usually, we focus on these elements and forget about covers and grounding. But in our opinion, they are essential for proper pool installation and insulation and protection against pollution when pol is not in use.
And luckily, almost all our constructions can boast these accessories.
Intex 28241EH and Intex 26725EH products are the best in this regard. Apart from the 15ft x 48in pools, customers also get free pumps (which we’ve already mentioned), a ladder, a cover, and a cloth.
Coleman Vista and Deluxe provide the same kit, except for the ground cloth. The lack is not that dramatic if you’ve already prepared a grounding area with leveling and decking.
When purchasing the compact Intex FBA pool, customers pay for the pool only. That’s why we see only a filter pump in its kit and no extra elements. Anyway, such a modest set justifies an affordable price.
verdictIndeed, the first two Intex products are our favorites. Coleman pools confidently keep up with the rivals and offer an equivalent toolset (especially if you can sacrifice the ground cloth). Intex FBA slightly loses against such background, but we believe that its price redeems the not-numerous kit.
Buyer’s Guide – How to Choose the Best Frame Pool?
Now when we highlighted all pools’ pros and cons, let us briefly remind you of the most important factors that influence the pool’s quality, durability, and suitability for your needs.
You can also find lots of offers with prism frames – these are bigger pools made of stronger alloy and reinforced pillars.
Almost all pools come with filter cartridge or sand pumps. You can also find a skimmer, a ladder, a ground cloth, a pool cover, a hose.
Conclusion
This was everything we’d like to tell you about Coleman vs Intex pools. The leading above-ground models are compared, strong and weak points are highlighted.
As usual, the final choice is yours. But we can state that all five pools will bring you joy and rest this summer.
Hi! I’m Markus Robertson, and water is my passion.
Five years ago, I graduated from the University of California-Los Angeles and was going to become a professional marine biologist. However, my fate had other plans for me, and due to family problems, I had to find a more stable and well-paid job. I had only one wish for my job to be connected with water.
During this period of my life, I worked as a sales manager at Olympic Pool & Spa Supplies. The job helped me learn everything about swimming pools and related pool equipment, as well as how to choose the best option and what to pay attention to.
