Jandy vs. Pentair pool pumps, which are the best and why? You are in the right place if you are torn between these two top brands. We have shared the main difference between the pool pumps from the two brands, the best models from Jandy and Pentair, and how they stack up against each other.
Jandy and Pentair are two household names in the pool pump industry. They are known for high-quality, reliable, and durable pool pumps. Their pool pumps share quite a lot in common. However, some differences should inform your purchase decision.
importantThe difference between Jandy and Pentair comes down to energy efficiency and usability. The Jandy pool pumps in this review are less energy efficient than Pentair. They also have fewer usability features. On the other hand, Pentair pool pumps are highly energy efficient and offer excellent usability.
For more regarding how Jandy compares to Pentair, read along.
Why Jandy?
Established in 1958, Jandy is a trusted brand known for its high-quality residential and commercial pool equipment, including heat pumps, pool pumps, heaters, filters, commercial valves, backwash valves, water sanitizers, rails and ladders, and so on. Today, Jandy is part of the larger Fluidra, which owns other top brands, including AstralPool, Polaris, Cepex, Zodiac, and CTX Professional.
If you are a pool owner, Jandy should be among the brands on your wishlist for several reasons. First, it is a reputable brand that doesn’t compromise product quality. All Jandy products are built with high-quality materials in the United States. Second, Jandy has a wide range of pool accessories. You can set up your entire pool infrastructure with Jandy equipment only. The prices are also fair compared to other top brands.
Best Jandy Pool Pumps
Jandy has a wide range of pool pumps. In this section, we have shared the best Jandy pool pumps on the market.
1. Jandy FHPM1.0 FloPro
Starting this countdown is the Jandy FHPM1.0 FloPro, a compact, versatile, and powerful pool pump designed for inground pools. One thing we like about the Jandy FloPro is its versatility. It can be installed on new construction and allows for effortless replacement of existing pumps.
The compact design and small footprint are also a plus, especially if you have limited space. Also worth mentioning is the inline connectivity that eliminates unsightly plumbing and pipes and the ergonomic cam-lock lid that tags along with alignment indicators making installation much easier. The base is adjustable, so you can easily replace the popular Hayward and Pentair pumps without many modifications. The discharge and suction ports are 2-inch while the recommended piping is 2 to 2.5 inches.
Under the hood, the medium-head Jandy FHPM1.0 FloPro packs a powerful 1.0HP Open Drip Proof (ODP) motor. Unfortunately, this is a single-speed motor, and moreso, it is not rated as Energy Efficient, and the WEF is 3.5. But all the same, it packs excellent power considering it delivers 1.24THP.
The Jandy FHPM1.0 FloPro is a great deal if you want an affordable pool pump. However, note it lacks any smart features, so if you are thinking of automation, you will have to extend your search elsewhere.
2. Jandy FloPro FHPM1.5
If you like the Jandy FHPM1.0 FloPro but feel it doesn’t get you enough power, you can opt for the Jandy FHPM1.5 FloPro. This compact, versatile, and powerful medium-head pool pump is designed for inground pools. It is also easy to install and has everything you need to set it up.
The Jandy FloPro boasts a compact design that allows for installation in tight spaces. For easy installation, it maintains the inline connectivity and ergonomic cam-lock lid with alignment indicators, so if you are a handy guy, you don’t need professional help to install it. We also like the adjustable base that makes it possible to replace pool pumps from other brands, including Hayward and Pentair pool pumps. Both discharge and suction ports are 2 inches, while the recommended piping is 2 to 2.5 inches.
The Jandy FloPro FHPM1.5 maintains a single-speed Open Drip Proof (ODP) motor. Like the Jandy FHPM1.0 FloPro’s motor, it is also not rated as Energy Efficient with a WEF rating of 5.6, but we like the fact that it offers quiet operation. Regarding performance, the motor, rated 1.5HP, delivers a cool 1.85THP.
Unfortunately, the Jandy FloPro FHPM1.5 is an entry-level pool pump with no smart or connectivity features, so you are locked out when it comes to the possibilities of automation.
3. Jandy Pro Series JEP2.0HP
If you are looking for an advanced pool pump from Jandy, the Jandy Pro Series JEP2.0HP should be number one on your wishlist. This robust pool pump blends energy efficiency and a safety mechanism so you can enjoy your pool time without any worries. Besides, it is a smart pool pump giving you much-needed convenience.
Like the other Jandy pool pumps listed above, the Jandy Pro Series is easy to install on any inground pool. It features an ergonomic cam-lock lid with alignment indicators and inline connectivity. The discharge and suction ports are 2 inches and 2.5 inches, respectively, while the recommended piping is 2-3 inches.
Under the hood, Jandy opted for a totally different motor. This is a Totally Enclosed, Fan-Cooled (TEFC) motor. Rated at 2.0HP, it delivers a cool 2.7THP, and surprisingly, it is very quiet, courtesy of Stealth Pump Technology. Also worth mentioning is that the Jandy Pro Series JEP2.0HP is a variable-speed pool pump that bolsters energy efficiency. As a matter of fact, this pool pump can save you $1,100 per year on energy costs. It has an impressive WEF rating of 7.2.
One outstanding feature of this pool pump is its safety. It is a VGB-compliant Safety Vacuum Release System (SVRS) that prevents full-body entrapment risks. We also like the fact that this is a smart model that allows for automation. It is compatible with the Jandy® AquaLink line of automation systems, for example, the iQPUMP01 or the JEP-R controller.
Why Pentair?
Pentair is also an American brand that started in 1966. The award-winning company is known for smart and sustainable water solutions for residential, commercial, and industrial water management. Unlike Jandy, its product offering goes beyond pools and spas. Pentair pool products include pool pumps, pool heating solutions, pool cleaners, pool water treatment solutions, valves, and pool automation devices, among others.
Pentair is an excellent choice if you want a brand with all the equipment you need to set up your pool infrastructure. One thing we like about Pentair is the quality in terms of craftsmanship. Its products are built using high-grade materials. Design and manufacturing is done in the United States.
Best Pentair Pool Pumps
Like Jandy, Pentair boasts a range of pool pumps. This section shares the top 3 best Pentair pool pumps that should feature in your wishlist.
1. Pentair SuperFlo® VS
The Pentair SuperFlo series has several models in the lineup, with the Pentair SuperFlo® VS 342001 Variable Speed Pool Pump as the best seller, even though it is discontinued. It has been replaced with the all-new SuperFlo® VST Pool Pump. But still, the Pentair SuperFlo® VS 342001 is still a favorite to many pool owners because of the good mix of features and affordability.
Installation is a buzz as the Pentair SuperFlo doesn’t require costly rewiring. The pump offers easy access to electrical components for simple installation. We also like the fact that the SuperFlo is a direct replacement for the Hayward® Super Pump, among several other pool pump models.
Operation is also straightforward. The pump has an intuitive user interface with a built-in 24-hour clock, 24-hour memory function, and graphical displays of crucial operational data. However, this is not a smart pool pump, so if you are thinking of automation, it is not the best pool pump for you.
This pool pump is designed for inground pools that require a pump of up to 1.5HP. Talking of power, the Pentair SuperFlo® VS, as the name suggests, comes with a variable-speed motor that delivers up to 2.2THP when firing on all cylinders. You can switch to any of the 3-speed settings. For the record, you can also use the override function.
The SuperFlo is an energy-efficient pool pump courtesy of the variable speed motor. It is Energy Star-certified and has a Weighted Energy Factor (WEF) of 9.0, which is impressive. The pump can save up to 80% of your energy costs if you use conventional single- or 2-speed pumps.
2. Pentair WhisperFlo VST
The Pentair WhisperFlo is another top-rated line of pool pumps from the American brand. The Pentair 011533 WhisperFlo VST Variable Speed Pool Pump is the best-selling model in the series. This is a new upgrade of the original WhisperFlo VS. So, what does it bring on board, and is it worth upgrading to?
Yes. The new Pentair WhisperFlo VST is a worthy upgrade now that it allows for RS-485 connectivity. Besides having an intuitive user interface with a display and several other features, the WhisperFlo VST is ready for automation. It is compatible with several Pentair automation systems and other IoT devices for flexibility.
When it comes to installation, the process is pretty straightforward. If you are the handy guy, you can do it by yourself. The WhisperFlo adapts to 115V and 230V or 50Hz and 60Hz power connections without any wiring modifications or switching requirements. The new WhisperFlo VST is a direct drop-in replacement for the older WhisperFlo VS.
Under the hood, the WhisperFlo packs a punch. It is powered by a 2.0HP Totally Enclosed, Fan-Cooled (TEFC) variable speed motor. There are 3-speed settings plus an override function. When at full speed, the WhisperFlo can deliver a cool 2.6THP. One interesting thing about this pump is the quiet operation, hence the name, WhisperFlo.
Onto energy efficiency, the Pentair WhisperFlo is an energy-efficient pool pump boasting the coveted Energy Star certification. With the WhisperFlo, you can cut your energy cost by up to 90% if you are using a single-speed pool pump.
3. Pentair IntelliFlo VS
The Pentair IntelliFlo VS series is a line of next-gen Pentair pool pumps designed for optimal performance, quiet operation, and energy efficiency. In this review, we have focused on the Pentair 011028 IntelliFlo VS, a discontinued model that is still available on the market. The IntelliFlo3™ VSF Pool Pump has replaced it, so should you stick to the old model or switch to the new variant?
Well, the older Pentair IntelliFlo VS is a great deal considering it is cheaper and has most of the features of the new IntelliFlo3™ VSF. To start, it requires simple installation. You don’t need a professional to come and install the unit if you are a handy guy. Besides, no rewiring or modifications are required to connect automation systems, and the wiring compartment is at the top for easy access.
When it comes to performance, IntellifFlo is just the best. It has been equipped with the same 3.0HP Totally Enclosed, Fan-Cooled (TEFC) motor that the new Pentair IntelliFlo3™ VSF Pool Pump comes with. This variable-speed motor with 8 programmable settings can deliver up to 3.95 THP.
When it comes to energy efficiency, IntelliFlo raises the bar. It is an energy-efficient pool pump with a Weighted Energy Factor (WEF) of 6.9, which is quite impressive.
Like the advanced pool pump, the Pentair IntelliFlo has a convenient, rotatable control keypad for advanced programming. The system is also compatible with Pentair automation systems for your convenience.
Jandy vs. Pentair Face-to-Face Comparison
Now that you understand why Jandy and Pentair are top-rated pool pump brands and their best sellers, it’s time to compare the two. To ensure you get the best out of this Jandy vs. Pentair comparison review, we will base our discussion on important factors considered when buying pool pumps. Without further ado, let’s get into it.
1. Design and Build Quality
The design of a pool pump, including its dimensions and weight, is an important consideration when selecting a pool pump. You definitely want a model with a simple design and a small footprint, especially if you are limited on installation space. Besides design, you should also focus on the build quality. You want a pool pump constructed from strong, sturdy materials that withstand harsh outdoor conditions and pool chemicals.
Pentair also boasts compact pool pumps that are space-saving. You can install the likes of Pentair IntelliFlo and WhisperFlo in tight spaces without much hassle.
As for build quality, Pentair is at par with Jandy as its pool pumps have been build using high-grade materials to withstand hard conditions during operation and when not in operation.
2. Application
As you may be aware, pool pumps are highly specialized depending on the pool type. There are pool pumps for inground pools only, while others are for aboveground pools only. Similarly, some are designed for both inground and aboveground pools. That said, assessing the types of pool pumps that Jandy and Pentair offer is essential.
On the other hand, Pentair has both aboveground and inground pool pumps. For those looking for aboveground pool pumps, the Pentair Dynamo and Pentaoir OptiFlo models will suffice.
As for inground pools, we have models such as the Pentair FloPro, WhisperFlo, and IntelliFlo.
3. Installation
Pool pumps come shipped in parts and will require installation. That said, you need to consider how easy or hard installing a particular brand’s pool pump is. This is especially if you are constructing a new pool. For those who are only replacing the pool, assess the compatibility with the older pool system.
Pentair pool pumps are also easy to install as they come with just a few components. Plus, the detailed guides on installation come in handy.
Pentair pool pumps are also similar to pumps from other brands, so if you want to replace another brand with Jandy, you won’t have to deal with lots of modifications. For example, the SuperFlo is a drop-in replacement for the Hayward® Super Pump, among other models.
4. Performance
The biggest consideration when buying a pool pump is its performance. You definitely want a pool pump with specifications that match your pool, whether it’s a small pool or a big pool. When it comes to the performance of pool pumps, the crucial aspects to consider include the motor’s design, horsepower, and total horsepower (THP).
Pentair, too, has something for all pool owners. Whether you have a small or large pool that requires a high-performance pool pump.
One thing we like about Pentair is that even the entry-level pool pups have a Totally Enclosed, Fan-Cooled (TEFC) variable speed motor. There is a 1.5 HP pump for small pools.
This is the Pentair SuperFlo® VS with a 3-speed setting and high power 3.0HP pumps such as the Pentair IntelliFlo with 8-speed settings.
5. Energy Efficiency
Let’s face it, pool maintenance greatly adds to your energy costs. But did you know not all pool pumps are power guzzlers? Yes. We have energy-efficient pool pumps optimized to ensure low power consumption. Definitely, you want a brand that emphasizes energy efficiency to reduce the bite on your monthly energy bills.
Pentair is the best brand when it comes to energy efficiency. To start, all the models in this comparison review, Pentair SuperFlo® VS, Pentair WhisperFlo VST, and Pentair IntelliFlo VS, are variable-speed pool pumps that can cut your energy costs by up to 90% if you are using single-speed pool pumps.
Interestingly, IntelliFlo has 8-speed settings. Besides, all the Pentair pool pumps in this review are ENERGY Star-certified.
The Weighted Energy Factor (WEF) for the SuperFlo, WhisperFlo, and IntelliFlo is 9.0, 8.4, and 6.9, respectively.
6. Usability
How user-friendly is the pool pump you want to buy? Where are the controls? Does it allow for automation? Usability is an important consideration when choosing the best pool pump to buy. Pool pumps have different usability features depending on the brand and price range. Some brands offer pumps with exceptional usability, while in general, it can be concluded that the expensive models have the best usability features.
Pentair is the best when it comes to usability. All the models featured in this comparison review come with an intuitive user interface that displays key information on the operation of the pump.
We also like the fact that the new replacements of the SuperFlo, WhisperFlo, and IntelliFlo all allow for automation.
7. Warranty and Aftersales
Does the pool pump you want to buy have a warranty? A warranty is essential just in case the pump malfunctions because of the manufacturer’s defects. In the same token, you want to assess aftersales service just in case you need support, supplies, or replacement parts.
Pentair, too, is known for durable pumps and generous warranties ranging from 1 to 3 years, depending on the pump type. Here, check the terms and conditions so you don’t unknowingly void the warranty.
Like Jandy, Pentair offers excellent support, and replacement parts and supplies are readily available.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. How long does a Jandy pool pump last?
A Jandy pool pump has been built to last and can serve you for 10 to 12 years on average if properly maintained. However, if you don’t properly use and maintain the pump, it can’t last for as long.2. Is Jandy made in the USA?
3. How long do Pentair pool pumps last?
4. Is Pentair better than Hayward?
5. How many hours a day should my Pentair pool pump run?
6. How much electricity does a Jandy pool pump use?
7. Is Jandy compatible with Pentair?
8. Is Pentair SuperFlo discontinued?
Wrapping Up
That’s the end of this Jandy vs. Pentair comparison review. As you have seen, both brands have high-quality, reliable, and durable pool pumps for all pool sizes. So, what’s the best brand? Well, overall, Pentair is the best choice as all its pool pumps in this comparison review have better energy efficiency and excellent usability. But still, you can’t rule out Jandy, as its pumps are less expensive and still offer excellent performance.
You can check out all the best Jandy pool pump discounts and the best Pentair discounts on Amazon today!
Hi! I’m Markus Robertson, and water is my passion.
Five years ago, I graduated from the University of California-Los Angeles and was going to become a professional marine biologist. However, my fate had other plans for me, and due to family problems, I had to find a more stable and well-paid job. I had only one wish for my job to be connected with water.
During this period of my life, I worked as a sales manager at Olympic Pool & Spa Supplies. The job helped me learn everything about swimming pools and related pool equipment, as well as how to choose the best option and what to pay attention to.
