Pool type, size, quality of water, pressure – all these factors directly influence the choice of compulsory pool systems like filters and a pump. The latter is especially important for proper maintenance.
The market offers us two types of pumps – single speed (only one speed available) and variable speed units (with several speed programs that alter automatically or manually). Today, we’d like to discuss the best-selling pool equipment brands – Hayward, Pentair, and XtremepowerUS – to compare top single speed vs variable speed pool pumps to offer.
While single products suit smaller pools, are easier for installation, use, and just cheaper, variable systems work with larger reservoirs, are smarter, and ensure a great energy economy. Let’s find out what product will suit your needs.
Main differences between single and variable speed pool pumps
There are two main types of pool pumps: single and variable speed. The differences are:
- Variable speed pumps can change water flow rate in the filtration system, while single speed pumps have only one speed – one flow rate.
- Maximum speed for a variable speed pump can be linked typically to the one speed in a single-speed pump. Usually, the speed and correspondingly the flow can be changed in variable speed pumps from 25 to 100 percent of the maximum level.
- As the filtration process does not require constant maximum flow, a variable speed pump allows saving energy.
- In variable speed pump, water through filtration system turns more times with less energy consumption during 24 hours per day that significantly improves the water quality in the pool (organics has no time to grow). The chemical treatment of the pool because of that can be performed fewer times per season, and the number of required chemicals will be smaller.
- Single-speed pumps are usually cheaper than variable speed drives with more service life and lower maintenance costs, as parts are used less than in variable speed drives.
SINGLE SPEED POOL PUMPS
Two brands take the leading positions in the single speed pump field – these are Hayward and Pentair models. The diversity of products will satisfy any customer but, at the same time, may make a choice a really tough thing.
Haywards support both pool types and offer more durable motors with anti-loading protection. Besides, they’re more affordable than Pentairs. Hayward is not a cheap brand, and even its simplest single speed pumps cost you up to $600 (still, an average price is $350-$400).
Pentair pool single speed pumps are rather aimed at inground pools. You get a higher GPM rate and larger, more convenient baskets with transparent lids.
So, here is a detailed comparison of brands and all their pumps.
Hayward Single Speed Pumps
The Hayward single speed section mostly uses the same base for all models. We can see similar heavy-duty, high-performance motors, large filter baskets, cooling systems, and even the same RPM rate in all pumps. Besides, weight and dimensions often coincide, so you will need standard space for installation.
importantPlease mind that single speed pumps provide simple installation and require no special tools. Some models like Hayward W3SP1593 PowerFlo Matrix can even change orientation from horizontal to vertical and vice versa.
However, Hayward produces separate pumps for inground and above ground pools, so please pay attention to this difference. Also, you can choose between 1 HP and a bit more powerful 1.5 HP devices.
Still, the main difference between the models lies in the GPM rate, which directly depends on the width of the port. The latter also varies from 1.5″ to 2″ (or there are models supporting both options). On average, you’ll get about a 5-7 psi increase at once.
As we said, Hayward offers the same motors. But if you’re looking for the most energy-efficient single speed pumps, we’d recommend you Hayward W3SP2307X10 MaxFlo XL and Hayward W3SP3007X10AZ Super II pool pumps with advanced hydraulics.
The manufacturer doesn’t provide info on debris baskets’ capacity, but you can choose between large units and extra-large units. Some pumps come with transparent covers for easy monitoring.
Also, all pumps we’re going to describe below are corded electric, but not all of them come with a cord in the kit. Cord length may also vary.
At the moment, users especially highlight the following five single speed pumps by Hayward. You can clearly see their main similarities and differences in our table.
Comparison Table
Last update on 2022-06-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
Pentair Single Speed Pumps
Pentair has lots of single speed pump models, but customers mostly like the following three products. As we’ve already mentioned, the brand supports inground pools; still, you can get a unit for above ground reservoirs too.
When it comes to RPM, Pentair features the same 3450 RPM standard for single speed pumps. But GPM rate reaches 100 points in all devices regardless of the HP motor level, etc.
By the way, motors are a bit simpler than in the Hayward pumps, though all are high-performance and heavy-duty. Pentair 340039 SuperFlo model is our leader here, thanks to the improved 56 square flange motor with highly engineered hydraulics.
The models coincide in filter baskets, too, both in dimensions and special see-through lids. Now, unlike the Hayward pumps, all models provide us with transparent basket covers. But you’ll see the difference in port sizes that vary from 1.5” to 2”.
Pentair primarily supports definite mounting orientation, but the 340210 Dynamo Above Ground pump offers us an easy access port with dual orientation both horizontally and vertically.
importantAnother reason to get a Pentair pump is strict UL/cUL listing and NSF certification.
For this review, we decided to take three best-selling Pentair single speed pool pumps. You can learn all their main characteristics, similarities, and differences in the table below.
Comparison Table
Last update on 2022-06-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
back to menu ↑VARIABLE SPEED POOL PUMPS
In this section, we’d like to discuss three pool pump brands – the well-known Hayward and Pentair and one more XtremepowerUS.
Variable speed pumps significantly differ from single speed models in many respects. Firstly, they provide more speed options that adjust automatically to pool needs or are set by users. Also, we notice better motors and higher HP rates.
However, smart speed adjustment allows for great energy savings. Variable speed modes mean extreme energy savings up to 90% compared to single speed pumps. Increased power means that pumps better suit large inground pools.
Finally, users love easy control through digital screens with multiple speed settings and timers.
The improved performance results in higher prices. Costs for variable speed pool pumps start from $1000, so they’re quite expensive. Still, you’ll redeem your investments later on electricity saving. So, let’s compare the best representatives of this class!
importantHere, we won’t provide you with GPM rates like in the single speed pump section as the exact GPM will vary greater depending on the speed chosen and the pool size. Please consult the manufacturer.
Hayward Variable Speed Pumps
If we compare Hayward single speed vs variable speed pool pumps, we’ll notice significant changes.
First of all, pumps became more powerful in terms of HP rate. Also, now motors support a special permanent magnet, totally enclosed fan cooled technology called TEFC. Thus, they are less subject to overloading, provide more power, and serve longer.
Pumps can automatically alter speed from 600 to 3450 RPM or support your 24-hour timer with 8 settings. Control became easier, too, thanks to a digital control interface. By the way, you can both mount the pumps in several options (standard and wall options) and adjust the interface position (four options) for your comfort.
The final improvement of Hayward variable speed pool pumps is compatibility with various automation systems like Omni Logic so that you can completely forget about manual controlling.
Let us mention that Hayward models are quite similar in many ways. The main differences between the products are HP rate, energy-saving level, port size, and some additional technologies. For example, only the Hayward SP3202VSP TriStar VS pump offers on-board motor diagnostics and automatic protection for the most widespread problems. And Hayward W3SP2603VSP Super Pump VS pump features a much quieter operation due to the hydraulic design.
In our review, Hayward variable speed pumps are represented by these two most popular models.
Comparison Table
Last update on 2022-06-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
Pentair Variable Speed Pumps
Pentair variable speed pumps share lots of features with Hayward devices. Thus, we notice the same top-level TEFC motors with cooling and load protection. Also, users have to pay a minimum of effort to customize the speed and durability of work since these pumps come with digital touch screens. A 24-hour timer is included, too, but the products differ in the number of speed modes and even RPM. This results in energy savings.
Here, we highlighted two Pentair models – Pentair SuperFlo VS Variable Speed Pool Pump 342001 and Pentair 011028 IntelliFlo VS Pool Pump. The first pump gives us 1.5 HP, while the second is twice more potent.
Like with Haywards, Pentair makes a division in terms of additional diagnostics protection. Only the IntelliFlo product boasts this technology. Besides, we can use the Pentair automation & controls support for pump independent work and phone control.
Pentair variable speed pool pumps are Energy Star certified and meet the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency & the U.S. Department of Energy requirements.
Comparison Table
Last update on 2022-06-25 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
XtremepowerUS Variable Speed Pumps
Unlike the previous models, XtremepowerUS provides two speeds. We include them in the variable speed pumps group since they can automatically change RPM, but in fact, we deal with dual speed devices.
XtremepowerUS pumps are quite different from other models in many respects. We see the same HP power and maximum RPM rates as in Haywards and Pentairs. But fewer speed options make them a nice choice both for large inground pools and smaller above ground reservoirs.
Also, the brand prefers using simpler heavy-duty, high-performance motors with air-flow ventilation that we noticed in single speed pumps. The further single speed vs variable speed pool pumps comparison shows XtremepowerUS pumps take a kind of transit position between both types since they also lack smart digital screens and timers for manual customization and scheduling.
However, a simpler design doesn’t mean worse performance. We have less convenient control and simpler motors, but the pool pumps are much more affordable for this reason. We believe XtremepowerUS dual speed pumps to be perfect for customers on a budget who would like to get some electricity savings (about 50%).
In our review, the brand is represented by two pool pump models – XtremepowerUS XP75034 Inground Pool Pump 5280GPH and XtremepowerUS XP75035 2HP In-Ground Swimming Pool Pump.
Comparison Table
Last update on 2022-06-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
back to menu ↑Main Brand Differences
Hayward, Pentair, and XtremepowerUS are all American pool equipment manufacturers. As usual, they share lots in common and, at the same time, feature some differences.
- Hayward can be justly called the oldest and most reputable name on our list. The company was founded back in 1925 and will soon celebrate its 100-year anniversary. Pentair has also deserved great respect for all these years passed since its establishment in 1966. Against such a background, XtremepowerUS seems to be a perspective and creative teenager as the company started its history in 2012 only.
- Hayward and Pentair are very similar in many ways. We notice the same motors, control technologies, power rates. However, Pentair is the most expensive manufacturer. Hayward is close to it in terms of prices, but you can find some reliable middle-priced models.
- XtremepowerUS differs more significantly. The brand offers simpler but much more affordable pool pumps. Thus, unlike the oldest manufacturers, it avoids wide usage of digital controls, timers, and other smart systems. Also, XtremepowerUS company produces universal pumps suitable both for inground and above ground pools. Its rivals usually specify on certain pool type.
Frequently Asked Questions
Hayward vs Pentair vs XtremepowerUS: what is the best pool pump for inground pools?
We’d recommend you to pay attention to Hayward SP3202VSP TriStar VS Variable-Speed Pool Pump. The model is ideal for the largest pools but still provides up to 90% energy saving, extra-durable motor, smart control, and on-board diagnostics.
Also, Pentair 011028 IntelliFlo VS Pool Pump is a decent and equal but more expensive option.
What is the best single speed pool pump?
Please, also mind Pentair brand with its Pentair 340039 SuperFlo and Pentair 340210 Dynamo pumps that stand aside due to compactness and high HP rate.
Can dual speed pool pumps be used in above ground pools and replace single speed pool pumps?
Where are Hayward, Pentair, and XtremepowerUS pool pumps made?
Conclusion
In this article, we tried to consider the most popular and efficient single speed and variable speed pool pumps by three leading brands.
In fact, the models don’t differ that much, but there are some unique technologies that can greatly influence performance and your choice (like HP, RPM, smart speed control, TEFC colling motors, automatic self-diagnostics).
Also, we can say that the market offers various pumps for any pool and customer. So, we hope you’ll find your perfect pool pump.
