The summer is fast approaching and temperatures are rising. Wouldn’t it be nice to have a pool in your backyard? Yup! I think so, too. That is why I decided to make a comparison between the Bestway Steel Pro vs. Steel Pro Max.
Building an in-ground pool is not a viable solution for all homeowners. Aside from the available space, you have to make sure it meets certain codes within your state. Not to mention, you will have to commit to paying taxes, insurances, and other ongoing maintenance costs. If you do not want to bother yourself with all that, your best option is an above-ground pool.
Our Expert Advice
I recommend frame pools as the first swimming pool in hot regions. Suppose you will not use it frequently or have a tight budget. Also, it is convenient for storage while not in use. For cold regions, frame pools are a cost solution. As summer is not very hot, the water temperature during most of the swimming season will not be enough for comfortable swimming. The thick vinyl walls will not keep the water temperature long; you always need to keep your heater running.
Main Differences
- Aesthetic-wise, I prefer the Bestway Steel Pro Max vs. Bestway Steel Pro. I particularly like the steel frame of the Bestway 56407 is dark grey, which I think is more appealing than the white metal frame.
- The interior of the Bestway Steel Pro Max™ has a beautiful mosaic print.
- The Bestway Steel Pro does not have three-ply reinforced PVC flap bands
Comparison table
1. Bestway Steel Pro (56407)
The Bestway 56407 comes in five sizes. Any of the shallow pools is ideal for families with young children who are becoming more adept at paddling. The deeper ones, on the other hand, are suitable for adults who like to get soaked while enjoying the warm weather buzz.
It isn’t a high-grade above-ground pool, but for the price, it gets the job done of keeping you cool and making unforgettable summer memories. The rails should withstand rough kids and dogs running around in the backyard.
If there is one thing I didn’t like, it is the pump and filter system, which I think is not as effective as I needed it to be. But overall, it is well worth the price. Whatever flaws it has can be addressed.
- A nice pool for the money
- Set up the pool in your backyard without any help
- Portable — move it anytime or bring it anywhere
- The liner is more durable than what others usually have and does not fade
- All metal components are prone to rusting
- The pump is slightly underpowered
2. Bestway Steel Pro MAX (56463)
If you have seen YouTube videos of above-ground pools breaking, this one is not it. I have seen this pool hold up to rowdy teenagers doing anything possible to damage it. Anyone can join the fun, including your doggie — just make sure his nails are trimmed!
With the introduction of the FrameLink System, the Bestway Steel Pro MAX boasts better protection against corrosion compared to previous models. It comes with enhanced T-connectors to lock the superior steel frame together. What’s more, each column is fitted with a TriTech™ support band.
This model also comes in three sizes, so you can choose appropriately based on your needs and available space. If possible, you should always opt for the 18 ft x 48 in.
- Remarkable strength of the steel frame and liner
- Each steel column is reinforced with a triple-layered support band
- Mosaic print interior
- Has wider, deeper options (biggest size comes with free accessories)
- Some consumers find the price a little over the top despite the pump being slightly underpowered
Face to Face Comparison
Now, let us take a closer look and compare the key features of the Bestway Steel Pro vs. Max.
Design and Dimensions
Both models feature the traditional round shape, which is a good thing. When it comes to above-ground pools, round ones have higher structural integrity due to the equal pressure applied to the walls.
The Bestway Steel Pro Max™ currently has three sizes available:
- Size A: 12 feet (diameter) x 2.5 feet / 30 inches (height)
Given the depth, Size A is geared towards families with children. - Size B: 15 feet (diameter) x 3.5 feet / 42 inches (height)
Size B is not deep enough for swimming, but it will give you ample space to lounge around with a small group of friends. - Size C: 18 feet (diameter) x 4 feet / 48 inches (height)
Size C is perfect for gathering more family members during barbecue nights. Likewise, it is the perfect choice if you are looking forward to water-bound drinking parties with close friends. This pool can hold approximately 7, 600 gallons of water.
The Bestway Steel Pro™, on the other hand, has five size options to choose from:
- Size A: 10 feet (diameter) x 2.5 feet / 30 inches (height)
- Size B: 12 feet (diameter) x 2.5 feet / 30 inches (height)
- Size C: 14 feet (diameter) x 2.75 feet / 33 inches (height)
- Size D: 15 feet (diameter) x 3.5 feet / 42 inches (height)
- Size E: 15 feet (diameter) x 4 feet / 48 inches (height)
verdictThe size difference might seem insignificant to others, but it’s a big deal for those who have limited space in their backyard.
I appreciate Bestway for making sure its patrons have many choices. But as for the size, you only get to choose one for both models. If your budget allows it, why not opt for the biggest size?
Frame and Assembly
To hold the pool together, the Bestway Steel Pro Max™ comes with a set of vertical pool legs and top rails that you lock together using “T” connectors and “C” clips.
Otherwise known as the Seal & Lock System™, this patented design guarantees that each joint connection is secure. Each post also has its own TriTech™ support band to conceal the attachments and provide a fail-safe.
The same applies to the Bestway Steel Pro. After all, this model has the same tube structure + liner design as the other.
On the downside, the metal parts of both products will rust eventually. People complained their pools showed rusting within a year or two, despite the corrosion-resistant coating.
verdictSo, you may need to be a little creative on how to delay that problem.
Liner
If you live in a humid environment, your pool liner may deteriorate even before the metal poles show signs of abuse. Thankfully, this is not the case with the Bestway Steel Pro™ and Steel Pro Max™.
The liners are made of TriTech™, Bestway’s proprietary material. For further clarification, it comprises PVC mesh sandwiched between two layers of heavy-gauge PVC. That said, it provides the pool better performance in terms of puncture and tear resistance.
However, the Bestway Steel Pro does not have a mosaic print interior. While the print is not a dealbreaker, it does add flair to your pool. Additionally, a stone print exterior is available for the Steel Pro Max™ if you don’t like the solid Royal Blue color.
Filter Pump and Draining Valve
The Bestway Steel Pro Max™ includes a filter pump. According to the manufacturer, the filter cartridges have antimicrobial properties to boot.
So, I recommend you buy an extra filter so that you can switch filters every week to keep your pool pristine. Better yet, get a bigger pump to fix this problem.
importantAnother complaint about this model is the draining hole, which is difficult to hold open when draining the whole pool. Likewise, its placement is a bit too high. You will have a good amount of water to empty using your good ole bucket.
Accessories
Advertisements may show a ladder, but only the Best Steel Pro Max™ 12’ x 48” size comes with a ladder, cover, and ground cloth.
ChemConnect™
ChemConnect™ is a chlorine tablet dispenser that you attach to the valve of the pool wall; thus, saving space. However, the person in charge of creating Amazon descriptions was unfortunately careful with the facts; thus, stirring a lot of confusion.
attentionThe Best Steel Pro and Best Steel Pro Max™ both lack the ChemConnect™ feature. ChemConnect™, however, is available in the more expensive Bestway Power Steel.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. How full should my Bestway Steel Pro Pool be?
Fill your Bestway Steel Pro pool 80% of its total water capacity.
2. Can I use an Intex pump on a Bestway pool?
3. How long do Bestway Steel Pro Max pools last?
4. Which is better round or rectangular pool?
5. How do you drain Bestway Steel Pro Max?
Recent Updates
Mar 15, 2023: There are some updates in the availability of Bestway Steel Pro MAX sizes and accessories. In addition to the three sizes described in the article, size D, E, and F are available:
Size C: 18 feet (diameter) x 4 feet / 48 inches height. It is available in mosaic and stone prints. Both come with a filter pump, a ladder and a pool cover.
Size D: 10 feet (diameter) x 2.5 feet / 30 inches height. No accessories.
Size E: 14 feet (diameter) x 2.75 feet / 33 inches height. No accessories.
Size F: 15 feet (diameter) x 4 feet / 48 inches height. It comes with a filter pump, a ladder and a pool cover.
Models that are not listed come without accessories.
Conclusion: Who is the Winner of this Battle?
The Bestway Steel Pro MAX is the upgraded version of the Steel Pro. It has all the features of the latter and more. While these pools are sturdy without a doubt, the pump and filter systems are not as stellar as its rival brands. However, many people are not surprised given the price they pay. To ensure your pool is kept clean round the clock, I recommend you to buy an Intex pump for any of these models.
Hi! I’m Markus Robertson, and water is my passion.
Five years ago, I graduated from the University of California-Los Angeles and was going to become a professional marine biologist. However, my fate had other plans for me, and due to family problems, I had to find a more stable and well-paid job. I had only one wish for my job to be connected with water.
During this period of my life, I worked as a sales manager at Olympic Pool & Spa Supplies. The job helped me learn everything about swimming pools and related pool equipment, as well as how to choose the best option and what to pay attention to.
Is it possible to buy Bestway 56061US Steel Pro MAX and set a sand filter pump instead of the weak cartridge one? Thanks!
Hello, Liza! Thank you very much for your question! Indeed, original filter pumps that come with above ground pools are not always powerful and durable enough. So, you can easily replace yours with a better sand filter model. We’d only recommend you choosing a pump of the same brand presented in your pool for an optimal match.
Hi! Is a standard water pump powerful enough for the stated pool capacity?
Hi, Greg! Thank you very much for your question. Bestway original water pumps are designed to manage exactly those loads offered by the capacity of the pools. However, many experienced users may find it insufficient (especially if you use additional equipment, etc.). That’s why we like the original pumps but recommend set more powerful analogues. You can read more about popular water pumps in our Best Variable Speed Pool Pump in 2022 comparison.
What is the best pool size for family use? I’m looking for a model suitable for two children, parents and perhaps small parties with friends.
Hi, Jonathan! Thank you very much for your question! For big families and small pool parties we’d recommend choosing frame pools not smaller than 14 feet x 2.75 feet x 33 inches. However, the bigger, the better, that’s why such size options as 15 feet x 3.5 feet x 42 inches and 15 feet x 4 feet x 48 inches are perfect.
Hello! A couple of years ago I had a small inflatable Intex pool for kids and we suffered a lot from birds. These little things loved swimming and drinking this water which was definitely not safe. I didn’t manage to find any cover for the pool. Are there special covers for Bestway Steel Pro (separately or included in the kit)?
Thank you very much for your question! Bestway Steel Pro and Bestway Steel Pro MAX do not offer pool covers in their kits. However, you can purchase this accessory separately on Amazon or directly from the manufacturers’ official website. Besides, both models come with water-sanitizer accessory ChemConnect which protects water from possible harmful particles.
Hi Marcus! If I use a sand filter, can I skip chemical water treatment? I hate chemicals and fear they harm my body and I will have cancer afterward.
Hello Lori! Thank you for your interest in water treatment. Sand filters with regular water recirculation and proper maintenance can remove suspended solids, improve water color and odor, and remove up to 99% of pathogens, including bacteria. But still, you need to constantly check the water pH and balance it at levels 7-7.6 (sand filters change water pH) and add chemicals to remove residues of bacteria and viruses. Also, it is recommended to organize chemical water treatment at the beginning of the swimming season. If you perform all steps correctly, the chemicals will be balanced and never harm you.
I need help getting the right size heater for a 9000 gal intex pool 12 x 14 x 52 that heats to 80 or more degree without hurting the liner thanks
Does a steel frame solid to withstand water pressure and mechanical impacts for years (at least 2-3). Thank you for response
Thank you very much for your question! Yes, steel frames can hold from 5300 to 7600 gallons of water. Besides, they will not deform in case of accident impact (for example if you play in the pool and hit the frame with your body part/ball/etc.)
If I dig a hole in the ground, can I put the pool there to make it an underground pool? I would like to have a sun deck, install lounges there. It would be like a perfect rest zone.
Hello Gladys! Thank you for your question! Bestway Steel Pro and Pro Max are not designed to withstand soil pressure if you put the pool inside the ground. But you can make these pools underground if you leave a distance to the soil for filters, pumps, and pool maintenance. However, be aware that you face a lot of additional expenses for excavations, sun deck installation, and soil storage. In case of any problems or damages to the pool, the warranty also will not work, as these pools are not designed for this type of installation.